Cindy Collins
Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    111
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

5 out of 5 based on 121 ratings.
101 user reviews.
Includes 10 Zillow reviews
Photo of Cindy Collins
Cindy Collins
See My Zillow Profile

What can I say …she sold my home in one day. She was fast to accomplishing everything from start to finish. She was very thorough, fun, and end the end became a friend. Anybody would appreciate having such an excellent realtor.

Susan Heinbaugh Susan Heinbaugh | Home Seller

Awesome to work with. Cindy was endorsed specifically to me as a realtor noted with distinction that I would have been terribly remiss not to contract with if able. She was tireless in her efforts to help me find and secure the house that was right for me. She guided me through a multitude of setbacks and difficulties endured during the various stages providing the best advice, adapting contracts to changing conditions, and helping to identify solutions. Would highly recommend.

Michael Howard | Home Buyer

Cindy Collins was absolutely amazing to work with on our second investment property with her! Even though the seller didn’t have a realtor, Cindy stayed on top of everything, kept communication flowing, and made sure we crossed the finish line. Her dedication, organization, and calm approach made the entire process so much easier. We are beyond grateful for her support and would highly recommend her!

Stacey Foreman | Home Buyer

We adore Cindy! She negotiated us into our perfect home. She stood up for us and made sure we got the best deal possible for our budget. Cindy is AMAZING!

Christian Balsimo | Home Buyer

Best Agent ever! Worked well an kept us informed throughout process. Assisted us with with every detail start to finish.

Susan Heinbaugh | Home Seller

Cindy was so easy to work with, and she really prioritized making sure my wife and I found the perfect home. She was diligent, easy to communicate with, and stayed on top of everything we needed. She made the home buying process easy and we couldn’t have asked for a better realtor!

Joseph Hurst | Home Buyer

Cindy is a joy to work with. Professional, tenacious, and so hard working! She has helped us purchase two homes in the past ten years, both requiring swift action. Cindy's immediate response (even when out of the country on vacation!) on our most recent purchase helped us seal the deal. Highly recommend!

Anita Newsom | Home Buyer

Working with Cindy on our first investment property was truly a pleasure. She brought so much knowledge and expertise to the table, and her guidance made the entire process feel simple and manageable.She was always available to answer questions, explain next steps, and make sure we were comfortable with every decision. Her professionalism and supportive approach took all the stress out of buying our first rental property.We’re grateful for her help and highly recommend her to anyone looking for a reliable, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful real estate professional.

Working with Cindy was fantastic from start to finish. She was responsive and engaged the entire process. With her guidance, we know we got the absolute best value from selling our house.

Kyle Schmeltzer | Home Seller

Super easy to work with and definitely a go-getter. Can't recommend her enough, we used her to purchase our first house and she made the process extremely easy from start to finish

Dillon Milless | Home Buyer

We decided to move to the area to be closer to our daughter and her new husband, and Cindy was recommended. We felt very comfortable and at ease from the moment we met her. She was ALWAYS available and very quick to respond to EVERY call or text. We were long distance so it was certainly not the easiest process. She is very knowledgeable about the local market and very personable. Cindy was really delightful to work with and, of course, found us our home. She will take good care of you!

Mark and Cheryl Bradley | Home Buyer

Cindy was amazing throughout this process! She was quick to get back to us to answer questions and was supportive of our needs and requests! She is also super knowledgeable about the market and helped us make informed decisions. Highly recommend Cindy and her team.

Lisa Ruff | Home Seller

Cindy came highly recommended by a trusted friend. She is very personable and always professional. Always available which was highly appreciated. She did an outstanding job of making my forever home “ Dream Come True”. Highly recommend for a stress free purchase.

Carol Pugh | Home Buyer

We couldn't have asked for a better realtor to sell our home. Cindy went above and beyond to make our sale seem easy from the listing to the closing table. She was always available to answer any questions that we had day or night. We couldn't have done it without her by our side. Thank you again for all of your help. The Byers Family

Stacy and Eric Byers | Home Seller

I’m so happy that Cindy was recommended to me by a friend. She made the process of selling my home seem easy. Even before I was ready to list it, she walked through my home and gave me tips about updates that would make the house more desirable to buyers and would get the best return. When I was ready to list, she explained the process well and made what was a difficult and emotional decision to sell feel comfortable. I loved the marketing photos and video. Communication was great! Cindy will be helping me when I’m ready to buy my next home, and I highly recommend her for everyone’s real estate needs.

Mary Van Almsick | Home Seller

I could not suggest Cindy enough. She did a phenomenal job answering any questions getting us any answers needed or anything throughout the whole process of getting the property. I could not suggest her enough and will suggest her any chance we get for buying or selling property!!!!

Darren Hunter | Home Buyer

Working with Cindy was a FANTASTIC experience, from start to finish! We are so grateful that our previous realtor, who retired, referred us to Cindy. Their assessment of Cindy’s character and work ethic was spot on. Cindy walked us through the entire process of finding and purchasing land, as well as preparing for our new build. While we had purchased a home in the past, the process of buying raw land was a vastly different experience, one that was made much easier with Cindy in our corner. She was knowledgeable, responsive, and detail-oriented throughout our search for our forever place. Cindy’s professional guidance and proactive communication helped us feel completely at ease during the process. When we hit roadblocks with other parties during the purchase, she was quick to make calls, find answers, and resolve issues promptly, putting our minds at ease. Her support was unmatched, and we wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell!

Amber & Travis Fisher | Home Buyer

Cindy has been great to work with during the process of selling and buying our home. She never failed to answer any of our questions and was always communicating with us!

Matt Fritz | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Cindy has been amazing to work with during the process of selling our home and purchasing our next! She never failed to answer any of our questions!

Hailie Fritz | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Cindy was very helpful in buying & selling our homes. The transactions were smooth and simple! We appreciate all of Cindys help as we navigated unfamiliar territory. We also cannot thank Andrea enough for everything she did during our transactions!

Courtney Salyer | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Working with Cindy was a great experience! As a first-time homebuyer, I had so many questions, but she was always there with clear and thoughtful communication. Her advice, based on years of experience, was invaluable and helped me make confident decisions throughout the process. She made what could have been a stressful journey enjoyable and straightforward. I couldn't have asked for a better guide to help me buy my first home!

Stephen Broussard | Home Buyer

We used Cindy a few years ago to purchase our first house and when we decided we’ve outgrown it, we knew we wanted to use her again to represent us as a seller and a buyer. She is very knowledgeable and always answered the many questions and scenarios we threw at her! The sale of our house went smoothly and we know she will help us with finding the perfect house for our family!

Brianna Carver | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Cindy did an outstanding job as our realtor! We had a flexible timeline buying our first home, but she was able to make it happen fast. As first time homebuyers, in a discouraging market, Cindy directed us to buy a reliable home to fit our needs. We never felt led astray and we were able to ask every question under the sun. Cindy is a fantastic balance of professional, personable, thoughtful, kind, and responsive. Any need we had, she covered. We felt very well cared for and would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell in the area. We couldn’t do it without you, Cindy!

Kiersten Lent | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Cindy did an outstanding job as our realtor! We had a flexible timeline buying our first home, but she was able to make it happen fast. As first time homebuyers, in a discouraging market, Cindy directed us to buy a reliable home to fit our needs. We never felt led astray and we were able to ask every question under the sun. Cindy is a fantastic balance of professional, personable, thoughtful, kind, and responsive. Any need we had, she covered. We felt very well cared for and would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell in the area.We couldn’t do it without you, Cindy!

Cindy did an excellent job helping us both purchase our new home and sell our first home (which she also helped us purchase in 2020)! She was extremely considerate and listened to our wants and needs. We appreciate her kindness & honesty, and will recommend her to work with anyone! ❤️

Sadie Kimble | Home Seller & Home Buyer

My wife and I were lucky enough to have Cindy help us sell and purchase a home. Cindy is a very friendly, knowledgeable and compassionate agent. She made the process very easy for us and we can’t thank her enough. We highly recommend Cindy and will definitely work with her again if the opportunity comes!

Steele Gaumer | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Cindy helped us while we were both selling a home and buying a new one simultaneously. It was not an easy process, but she was available when we had questions, and she was able to provide many ways in which we could increase the value of our home in order to make the most profit. She walked us through several headaches and helped us find a nice home, even in a tough market and time crunch. We appreciate everything that she did for us!

Cindy is so easy to work with and her responsiveness feels super-human. She helped me to simultaneously (and unexpectedly) buy and sell a house, which felt like an overwhelming task until I started working with Cindy. She strikes the perfect balance between professional and personal and will advocate for her clients to the bitter end. Incredibly knowledgeable and proactive, she helped me close on two properties in less than a month, which was a whirlwind of administrative work. Cindy did not miss a beat. I highly recommend Cindy for any and all things real estate.

Alicia Woods | Home Buyer

Enough cannot be said of Cindy's real estate expertise and her ability to clearly convey the message to her clients and the broader community. But, the best thing is that she is an even better person to work with on any project, purchase/sell or project!

Vonnie McDonald | Home Seller

Cindy was instrumental in our first-time home buying process. She does an incredible job of walking you through the process from beginning to end and it is clear that she is truly an expert in the field. She advocates for her clients and answers any and all questions in a timely fashion. Her assistant, Jake, was also extremely helpful and responsive throughout the process. I would highly recommend Cindy to be your realtor.

Jake Mogan | Home Buyer

I highly recommend Cindy. She helped me to simultaneously buy and sell a house, which is a lot of work and requires someone who is knowledgeable, responsive, and a clear communicator. Cindy is all of those things and more. Because of Cindy's expertise, the experience was quick and relatively painless. I can tell Cindy is a tireless advocate for her clients. She helped me every step of the way and went above and beyond for me when it came time for negotiations. She is professional and personable and at times it felt like she was not just my real estate agent, but my therapist and friend. You cannot find a better agent than Cindy Collins.

I have worked with Cindy 7 times now. 5 times I've been the buyer and 2 times I've been the seller every time she's made it very easy for me. Also I would like to add the 7 transaction were through all kinds of different markets from 2012 through 2023. If you're reading this just do yourself a favor and give her a call.

Jason Russell | Home Buyer

Cindy helped me through the process as a 1st time home buyer and I couldn't be happier!

Blake Barr | Home Buyer

Cindy is amazing to work with and will help you with any property you want to sell or buy. Her experience professionalism winning attitude, make it a hassle and stress free process. Buying or selling a property can be very stressful for a lot of people but she will be by your side before during and after the sale. Would definitely work with her again. By far she surpasses the competition with her honesty integrity knowledge and attitude. Incredible!

Cole Trew | Home Seller

My sister and I loved working with Cindy on selling our mom's condo. Cindy is excellent realtor. She got us more than we were asking for. Cindy is easy to work with and followed thru on everything. Thank you so much Cindy, we appreciate all you done for us.

Linda DeBoe | Home Seller

Cindy took control! Cindy communicated with all parties involved and our part was effortless.

David Renaud | Home Buyer

I would HIGHLY recommend Cindy as your realtor! She was incredibly helpful and communicative. I felt like we were long-time friends or family. She made the whole process of buying our first home easier. My husband and I are truly grateful and will continue to use her for any future realty needs!

Marina Richter | Home Buyer

New Homebuyers as of 11/2023: We started this home buying process at the beginning of October 2023 - my spouse and I had reached out to a number of different realtors with no interest/response. Cindy was the only realtor to answer after the first couple of rings - Cindy also made herself available to us at all reasonable hours. Cindy provided detailed emails with descriptions of the homebuying process, and new listings. Jake (intern) filled in while Cindy was temporarily unreachable. Jake was professional, well versed in his industry. All in all: Cindy and her team worked hard for me. I appreciate her dedication, willingness to listen, and "go getter" attitude. I hope that I get the opportunity to work with her again in the future!

Jerick Richter | Home Buyer

Cindy was a great advocate for us with all parties involved during our buying and selling journey. She gave outstanding advice to help our home sell and made us feel confident to take the leap on our new home. She went above and beyond with marketing our sale with a “coming soon” video, posts and networking with other agents. We had several showings and an offer within 11 days. This allowed us the opportunity to buy a new home for our growing family. At times where we felt stressed, she gave us the confidence we needed to make it through the process smoothly with both transactions. We came to Cindy with specific goals and we could not have achieved them without her expertise!

Katie Arnold | Home Seller

Cindy was a great advocate for us with all parties involved during our buying and selling journey. She provided great insight and led us with confidence while reaching our goals!

Katie Arnold | Home Buyer

Cindy did an amazing job guiding us through the selling process. She identified some key areas that needed improvement to get our maximum revenue, was willing to provide contacts if we couldn’t do the work and gave motivation to get them done throughout. In the final selling process, she was able to get our house into contract shortly thanks to her advanced marketing techniques. We really loved the videos of our home! She answered any questions we had throughout the closing process to a smooth and expedited finish!

Tony Davis | Home Seller

Cindy was a great advocate for us with all parties involved during our buying and selling journey. She provided great insight and led us with confidence while reaching our goals!

Cindy is hands down the best! We just purchased our first home with her and it was a smooth, organized, and stress less process. Cindy is a friend of my coworker and she highly recommended her for us, so I reached out and the same day of contacting her she had things underway. I received her contact information, she asked for mine, she took interest immediately in what we wanted and where! She was available for us 24/7 text, call or email! Her knowledge of the job helped us tremendously as we are first time buyers. We couldn’t be more thankful we contacted her! Whether you are seasoned or new to buying or selling, Cindy is the realtor for you!

Courtney Fulton | Home Buyer

Cindy Collins and Jake Shamblin were exceptional to work with when selling my home this last month. From day one, Cindy was available, knowledgeable, proactive and professional. At no time did I feel in the dark and she made the whole process stress-free. I will continue to recommend Cindy to family and friends, as I couldn't have had a better experience. Thank you, Cindy and Jake!

Kate Smiley | Home Seller

Cindy partnered with us for over two years as we decided what our next real estate adventure would be. She was patient, energetic and knew her book of business and the market areas well. She made sure the whole family was included in the process including our kiddos. She was not overbearing which we appreciated. She is wonderful to work with!

Jessica Matheny | Home Seller

Cindy was patient in helping us find a home that met our needs in a difficult market. Her ability to write a good offer to the seller based on what we bid was key in getting us into contract. We appreciated her knowledge of the buying process.

Melissa Shank | Home Buyer

Cindy was patient in helping us find a home that met our needs in a difficult market. Her ability to write a good offer to the seller based on what we bid was key in getting us into contract. We appreciated her knowledge of the buying process.

Cindy Collins and Jake Shamblin were exceptional to work with when selling my home this last month. From day one, Cindy was available, knowledgeable, proactive and professional. At no time did I feel in the dark and she made the whole process stress-free. I will continue to recommend Cindy to family and friends, as I couldn't have had a better experience. Thank you, Cindy and Jake!

Kate Smiley | Home Seller

Cindy partnered with us for over two years as we decided what our next real estate adventure would be. She was patient, energetic and knew her book of business and the market areas well. She made sure the whole family was included in the process including our kiddos. She was not overbearing which we appreciated. She is wonderful to work with!

Jess Matheny

Cindy Collins and Jake Shamblin were exceptional to work with when selling my home this last month. From day one, Cindy was available, knowledgeable, proactive and professional. At no time did I feel in the dark and she made the whole process stress-free. I will continue to recommend Cindy to family and friends, as I couldn't have had a better experience. Thank you, Cindy and Jake!

Cindy is hands down the best! We just purchased our first home with her and it was a smooth, organized, and stress less process. Cindy is a friend of my coworker and she highly recommended her for us, so I reached out and the same day of contacting her she had things underway. I received her contact information, she asked for mine, she took interest immediately in what we wanted and where! She was available for us 24/7 text, call or email! Her knowledge of the job helped us tremendously as we are first time buyers. We couldn’t be more thankful we contacted her! Whether you are seasoned or new to buying or selling, Cindy is the realtor for you!

Courtney Fulton

Cindy is top notch, she is professional, compassionate and courteous. Highly recommend her!

Justin Spafford | Home Seller

We really enjoyed working with Cindy. She worked hard for us and was always available when we had questions. So far we sold our home and bought a new home within 45 days with Cindy’s help. We highly recommend Cindy to anyone who’s looking to buy or cell a home.Thank you again Cindy!Shannon & Shannyn

Cindy was awesome during the sale of our home. We sold our home before it was ever listed on MLS. Cindy explained everything in detail on what to expect before and after the sale. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home

Shannon Clyburn

Cindy was absolutely wonderful to work with. She truly is the BEST! She was personal, thorough, professional and great to work with. I can not say it enough but everyone needs a Cindy in their lives. I can’t even begin to say how many times I said that throughout our entire process. She would always come to the rescue when Tim and I had to make big decisions or just had a debate about what to do next. She always put my mind at ease and helped every step of the way. I highly recommend having Cindy represent you as a buyer or a seller. You will not be disappointed. #everyoneneedsacindy

Abbey Gaal

I can't say enough about Cindy's expertise in real estate. Her approach to selling houses is modern and efficient. And boy, does she get results! Once the house was in contract, we didn't need to worry about anything, Cindy handled it all. I can't recommend her enough!

Stephanie Mats

Cindy did a great job helping us navigate this crazy market. Thanks so much!!

Eric Glass

she is very professional, she was there with every question and concern we had. her knowledge of real estate was of expertise. she knew what we wanted and found things for us to change to make our house selling experience easy and comfortable. in my personal opinion we could be not of found a better agent for our needs.

Eric Irwin

Very professional and will definitely be working with her again. Thanks!

Allen Monk

Cindy was absolutely fabulous to work with in our recent move from the Fort Wayne, IN area down to Albany, OH. She was extremely helpful in helping us find our home, and even gave us some ideas for selling our former home!

Ashley Hemminger

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel